Strategy

Most Businesses Don’t Have a Marketing Problem... They Have a Math Problem

Most Businesses Don’t Have a Marketing Problem... They Have a Math Problem

Most businesses have a math problem, not a marketing one. Learn the strategy to master unit economics for profitable growth.

Most businesses think they have a marketing problem. They spend more money on ads, chase more leads, and try to get more traffic. But often, the real issue isn't getting more customers, it's understanding the numbers. If you're losing money on each sale, more sales just make the problem worse. This article explores how focusing on the math behind your business, rather than just marketing tactics, is the real strategy for growth.

Key Takeaways

  • Many businesses struggle not from a lack of sales, but from losing money on each transaction. More sales simply accelerate losses if the underlying economics are flawed.

  • Understanding your unit economics means knowing the true cost of delivering a product or service, including all hidden expenses beyond the initial price.

  • Improving business performance comes from mastering unit economics, focusing on accurate customer acquisition costs and customer lifetime value, not just chasing more traffic.

  • A strong business strategy involves shifting focus from sheer volume to profitability, optimizing pricing, conversion rates, and average order value.

  • Knowing your profit margins precisely is vital; scaling a business with unaddressed margin issues is a risky strategy that can lead to failure.

Understanding Your True Profitability: Beyond Top-Line Sales

Most business owners get excited about sales numbers. More sales, more revenue, right? Well, not always. Sometimes, chasing more sales can actually hurt your business if you're not careful. It's like driving a car faster and faster, but you forgot to check if there's gas in the tank. You'll just end up stranded, but with more debt.

Why More Sales Aren't Always Better

It sounds counterintuitive, but you can actually lose money on every sale you make. This happens when your costs to acquire a customer and deliver your product or service are higher than the price you charge. If you're not tracking your expenses closely, you might be spending more to get that sale than you're earning from it. More sales in this scenario just mean you're losing money faster. It's not about how many customers you have, but how much profit each one brings in.

The Hidden Costs of Every Transaction

Think about everything that goes into a single sale. For an online store, it's not just the cost of the item itself. You have to consider:

  • Shipping and handling fees

  • Payment processing charges

  • Marketing and advertising spend to attract the customer

  • Packaging materials

  • Customer service time

  • Platform fees (like Shopify or Amazon)

  • Returns and exchanges

For service businesses, it includes things like the time spent on discovery calls, administrative tasks, software subscriptions, and even the cost of your office space. If you don't account for all these, your profit margins can shrink to nothing, or even go negative.

Identifying Profit Leaks in Your Business

To really understand your profitability, you need to look beyond just the revenue number. You need to know your unit economics. This means understanding the exact cost associated with each product sold or service delivered. A good starting point is to aim for specific financial benchmarks:

  • Gross profit > 30%: This is what's left after you subtract the direct costs of producing your goods or services.

  • SG&A < 20%: Selling, General, and Administrative expenses are your operating costs. Keeping these in check is vital.

  • Net profit > 10%: This is your bottom line – the actual profit after all expenses are paid.

If your business isn't hitting these basic targets, you likely have profit leaks. These aren't always obvious, and they can drain your resources without you even realizing it. Fixing these leaks is the first step to building a truly profitable and sustainable business, long before you worry about scaling up your marketing efforts.

The Core of Business Strategy: Mastering Unit Economics

a calculator sitting on top of a piece of paper

Most businesses don’t have a traffic problem. They have a math problem. More sales sounds good, but if you're losing money on each one, more sales just makes the problem worse, faster. This isn't about getting more people to see your stuff; it's about making sure the people who do pay attention actually make you money. That's where unit economics comes in. It’s the bedrock of smart business growth.

What Unit Economics Truly Means for Your Business

Unit economics boils down to knowing, with certainty, what it costs you to deliver one unit of your product or service. And I don't just mean the basic cost of goods. Think about everything. For an online store, it's not just the $30 you paid for the item. It's that $30, plus import fees, warehousing, shipping, payment processing fees, your website platform costs, salaries for your team, customer service time, and all your marketing and ad spend. That 40% markup you thought covered everything? It's probably not enough. You might be running at a loss without even realizing it.

Service businesses aren't exempt. If you're a consultant, designer, or therapist, your hourly rate might look good on paper. But did you factor in the time spent on discovery calls, admin, follow-ups, or software subscriptions? If not, you're likely leaving serious profit on the table.

Calculating Your Cost Per Acquisition Accurately

Knowing your cost per acquisition (CPA) is vital. It’s not just about the ad spend. It includes all the costs associated with getting a customer through the door, from the first ad they see to the final sale. This means factoring in ad costs, content creation, sales team salaries, and any software used in the sales process. A common mistake is only looking at direct ad spend, which gives you a skewed, overly optimistic view of how much it really costs to get a new customer.

Defining Your Customer Lifetime Value

Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) is the total amount of revenue a single customer is expected to generate for your business over the entire period they remain a customer. This is where the real magic happens. A business that can spend more to acquire a customer wins, but only if that customer spends enough over time to make it profitable. Focusing on increasing CLV through repeat purchases, upsells, and excellent customer service can dramatically change your profitability. It allows you to invest more confidently in acquiring new customers, knowing they'll be valuable long-term.

Consider this simple breakdown, often referred to as The 30/20/10 Rule in some circles, though the exact percentages can vary:

  • 30%: Allocate this portion to customer acquisition costs (marketing and sales).

  • 20%: Set aside for operational overhead (salaries, rent, software).

  • 10%: This is your net profit margin. The remaining 40% covers the direct cost of your product or service.

If your acquisition costs are higher than 30%, or your profit margin is less than 10%, you have a problem that more sales won't fix. It means you need to adjust your pricing, improve conversion rates, boost average order value, or increase customer lifetime value to make the math work.

Leveraging Math for Smarter Growth and Scaling

Most businesses think growth means just getting more customers, more traffic, or more sales. But if your basic numbers aren't working, more of that just makes the problem bigger. The real way to grow smart is to get good at the math behind your business. It’s about making sure each step you take actually makes you more money, not just more work.

The Power of Pricing Strategy in Profitability

Think about your prices. It’s one of the most direct ways to change your profit. If you sell something for $100 and it costs you $50 to make and sell, you have a $50 profit. If you can sell that same item for $120, and your costs stay the same, your profit jumps to $70. That’s a big difference, right? It’s not just about selling more; it’s about selling at a price that reflects the value you provide and covers all your costs, plus a good profit.

  • Raising prices, even slightly, can have a huge impact on your bottom line.

Improving Conversion Rates for Sustainable Growth

What if you could get more people to buy from you without needing to find more people in the first place? That’s where conversion rates come in. If 100 people visit your website and 2 buy something, that’s a 2% conversion rate. If you can get 4 people to buy from those same 100 visitors, you’ve doubled your results without spending more on ads or getting more traffic. This means you can spend more on acquiring those customers because you know they’re more likely to buy.

Here’s a simple look at how it works:

Metric

Scenario A (2% CR)

Scenario B (4% CR)

Visitors

100

100

Conversion Rate

2%

4%

Sales

2

4

Revenue (Avg $50/sale)

$100

$200

Focusing on making your existing traffic more likely to convert is often a much more efficient way to grow than simply trying to attract more people.

Boosting Average Order Value Strategically

Another way to make more money from the customers you already have is to get them to spend a bit more each time they buy. This is your Average Order Value (AOV). If customers typically spend $50, but you can encourage them to add another item or upgrade to a more expensive version, maybe they spend $65 instead. That extra $15 per order adds up quickly, especially if you have many customers. Think about offering bundles, suggesting related products, or having a tiered pricing structure. It’s about making it easy and appealing for customers to spend a little more with you.

Here are a few ideas:

  • Offer product bundles that provide a slight discount compared to buying items separately.

  • Suggest complementary products at checkout (e.g., "Customers who bought this also bought...").

  • Introduce premium versions of your products or services with added features or benefits.

Shifting Your Business Strategy from Volume to Value

pen om paper

Most businesses think they need more customers, more leads, or more website traffic. But honestly, if your current setup isn't making money, throwing more people at it just makes the problem bigger. It's like trying to fill a leaky bucket – you just end up wasting water. The real goal isn't just getting more eyeballs; it's about making sure the people who are paying attention actually buy something and keep buying.

Why Chasing More Traffic Can Be Detrimental

It sounds counterintuitive, right? More traffic equals more sales. But that’s only true if your business model is sound. If you're spending more to get a customer than they spend with you, then every new visitor is just a new way to lose money. Think about it: if it costs you $50 to acquire a customer, but they only spend $40, you're losing $10 on every single person. Adding more traffic just means you're losing $10 more often. It’s a quick way to go broke, even if your website looks busy. You need to fix the underlying math before you try to get more people in the door. It’s better to have a smaller, profitable audience than a huge, money-losing one. We need to focus on making each customer interaction count, not just racking up numbers.

Focusing on Profitability Over Mere Revenue

Revenue is just the top line; profit is what actually stays in your bank account. Many businesses get caught up in chasing revenue numbers, thinking that a higher sales figure automatically means success. But if your costs are too high, that revenue might not translate into actual profit. For example, selling 100 items at $10 each brings in $1,000 in revenue. But if those items cost you $9 each to make and sell, your profit is only $100. Now, imagine selling just 10 items at $50 each. That's also $500 in revenue, but if those items cost $20 each, your profit is $300. See the difference? It’s not about how much money comes in, but how much is left over after all expenses are paid. The business that can spend the most to acquire a customer wins, and that’s only possible if you’re profitable.

The Importance of a Solid Financial Strategy

Having a strong financial strategy means you understand your numbers inside and out. It’s not just about tracking sales; it’s about knowing your costs, your margins, and your customer lifetime value. This knowledge allows you to make smart decisions about where to invest your money, especially in marketing. For instance, if you know a customer is likely to spend $500 with you over time, you can afford to spend more upfront to acquire them than if they only ever spend $50. This understanding helps you set realistic goals and create a plan to achieve them. It’s about building a business that can handle market shifts, like those discussed in analyzing historical data, rather than just reacting to them. A solid financial strategy is your roadmap to sustainable growth, ensuring you're building value, not just activity.

Here’s a simple way to look at it:

Metric

Scenario A (Volume)

Scenario B (Value)

Price per Unit

$10

$50

Customers Acquired

100

10

Total Revenue

$1,000

$500

Cost per Unit

$9

$20

Total Cost

$900

$200

Total Profit

$100

$300

As you can see, focusing on value (Scenario B) can lead to significantly higher profits, even with fewer customers. This shift requires a different approach to marketing and sales, one that prioritizes customer relationships and increasing the value of each transaction.

Optimizing Your Sales Funnel Through Financial Acumen

Most businesses don’t have a traffic problem. They have a math problem. More traffic sounds like the answer, but if your funnel isn’t profitable now, adding more people to it won’t fix the problem. It’ll just amplify what’s already broken. Thankfully, there’s a better way. You don’t need more leads, more followers, or a bigger ad budget to grow. You just need to make better use of the people already paying attention. This is about doing exactly that: making better use of your existing customer base and leads.

The Math Behind Customer Acquisition Wins

Winning in business often comes down to who can spend the most to acquire a customer. This isn't about having the biggest budget, but about having the strongest unit economics. If you're losing money on every sale, more sales just make the problem worse. It’s like driving faster in the wrong direction – it looks busy, but it won't get you where you want to go. The business that can spend the most to acquire a customer wins. This means understanding your costs and your customer's value.

Analyzing Sales Math: Constants and Variables

Sales math isn't always straightforward. What used to work might not anymore. The number of outreaches needed to get a lead, or the number of leads needed for a sale, can change. Win rates, average deal values, and selling cycles are not fixed. They are variables that can shift. To improve your results, you need to look at these constants and variables. How can you change them to your favor before you even run the numbers?

Here are some areas to examine:

  • Offer Design: How can you improve your offer to increase conversion rates? Is your offer relevant and specific enough?

  • Average Order Value (AOV): Can you add upsells, cross-sells, or order bumps to increase the value of each purchase?

  • Authority and Social Proof: Incorporating elements that build trust, like testimonials or case studies, can improve conversion rates.

  • Customer Lifetime Value (LTV): What mechanisms are in place to encourage repeat business and increase the total value a customer brings over time?

  • Overhead Reduction: Can you decrease your cost of goods sold (COGS) or operating expenses to improve overall profitability?

Improving your economics, even slightly, can unlock more budget, more scale, and more freedom to grow. It’s about working smarter, not just harder.

Improving Win Rates for Efficient Scaling

Improving your win rates is a direct way to boost profitability without needing more leads. Think about your sales process. Are there ways to make it more effective? This could involve better training for your sales team, refining your sales scripts, or improving the follow-up process. A solid financial advisor sales funnel, for example, focuses on nurturing leads effectively through each stage. By understanding the financial implications at each step, you can identify where deals are being lost and implement strategies to improve your close rates. This makes your entire sales effort more efficient and profitable, allowing for more predictable scaling. You can find resources to help structure your sales funnel effectively.

Consider these prompts to improve your sales math:

  1. How can I improve the conversion rate through offer design?

  2. Where can I infuse authority, credibility, and social proof into my sales process?

  3. What mechanisms can I implement to boost customer lifetime value (LTV) after the initial purchase?

The Strategic Advantage of Knowing Your Margins

Most business owners get this wrong. They look at their sales numbers and think, "Great, we sold a lot this month!" But what they're not doing is looking at the real profit after all the costs are accounted for. It’s like looking at the speedometer on your car and thinking that’s how fast you’re going, without checking if you’re actually in gear.

Don't Guess Your Margins, Know Them

Seriously, stop guessing. If you don't know exactly how much money you make on each sale after everything is paid for, you're flying blind. This isn't just about the cost of goods sold. Think about all the little things: shipping, payment processing fees, customer service time, returns, even the cost of the software you use to manage everything. For an e-commerce business, that $30 product might have $25 in hidden costs before it even gets to the customer. For a service business, that hourly rate needs to cover your admin time, marketing efforts, and software subscriptions, not just your personal salary.

  • Calculate all direct costs: Materials, labor, shipping, transaction fees.

  • Factor in indirect costs: Marketing spend, software, rent, utilities, salaries.

  • Determine your true profit per unit: Revenue per unit minus all associated costs.

If you're not profitable on every single transaction, then more sales just means you're losing more money, faster. It feels like progress, but it's actually just digging a deeper hole.

Scaling with Broken Margins: A Risky Endeavor

Imagine you're trying to drive across the country, but your car has a slow leak in the gas tank. You can keep filling it up, and you'll keep moving, but you're constantly losing fuel. Scaling a business with bad margins is exactly like that. You might be spending more on ads, hiring more people, and seeing higher revenue numbers, but if each sale isn't actually making you money, you're just accelerating your own financial problems. It looks busy, it feels like growth, but you're not getting closer to your destination – which is a healthy, profitable business.

Fixing Margins Before Pressing the Gas

Before you even think about spending more on advertising or trying to get more customers, you must get your margins right. This means understanding your unit economics inside and out. Once you know your true profit per sale, you can then figure out how to increase it. This might involve:

  • Adjusting your pricing: Even a small price increase can have a big impact on profit.

  • Reducing costs: Look for efficiencies in your operations or supplier agreements.

  • Increasing average order value: Encourage customers to buy more items or higher-priced items.

  • Improving customer lifetime value: Focus on repeat business and customer loyalty.

The business that can spend the most to acquire a customer wins, but only if they have the margins to support it. Get your math right first, then you can confidently hit the gas.

It's All About the Numbers, Not Just the Noise

So, really, it comes down to this: stop chasing every new marketing trend or hoping more leads will magically fix things. Most of the time, the real issue isn't that you're not getting enough attention; it's that the attention you are getting isn't turning into profit. Before you spend another dime on ads or fancy campaigns, take a hard look at your numbers. Know exactly what it costs to make a sale, what you actually earn from it after all expenses, and where you can tweak things like pricing, conversion rates, or how much customers spend over time. Fix those underlying economics first. Once your math is solid, then you can confidently hit the gas and grow your business the right way, without just spinning your wheels.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is having more sales not always a good thing for a business?

Sometimes, businesses can sell more products or services but still lose money on each sale. If a business isn't making a profit from each customer, selling more just means losing more money faster. It's like trying to fill a leaky bucket – the more water you pour in, the more spills out.

What does 'unit economics' mean in simple terms?

Unit economics is all about understanding the real cost of making and selling one single item or service. It's not just the price you pay for materials. It includes everything from making the product, shipping it, paying for ads to find customers, and even customer service costs. Knowing this helps you see if you're actually making money on each sale.

How can businesses make smarter growth decisions using math?

Businesses can grow smarter by looking closely at their numbers. This includes setting the right prices for their products, making it easier for customers to buy (improving conversion rates), encouraging customers to buy more each time (average order value), and keeping customers coming back over time (customer lifetime value). Focusing on these areas helps businesses grow without losing money.

What's the difference between focusing on volume and focusing on value?

Focusing on volume means trying to get as many customers or sales as possible, like chasing more website visitors. Focusing on value means making sure each sale is profitable and that customers are valuable over time. Chasing too many customers without profitable sales can actually hurt a business, while focusing on value builds a stronger, more stable company.

How does knowing your profit margins help improve sales?

Knowing your exact profit margins is crucial. If your margins are too small or negative, you're losing money on every sale. Businesses need to fix these 'broken margins' first before trying to sell more. It's like making sure your car's engine is running smoothly before trying to drive it faster. Fixing margins allows for sustainable growth.

What are some key numbers businesses should track to improve their sales process?

Businesses should track how much it costs to get a new customer (Customer Acquisition Cost), how much money a customer brings in over their entire relationship with the business (Customer Lifetime Value), and how often customers buy from them (conversion rates). They also need to know their profit on every single sale. Understanding these numbers helps businesses make better decisions about where to spend their money and how to improve their sales.

Examine more articles

Braymonte partners with founders in tech, finance & healthcare to scale fast with elite marketing, systems, and strategy. This isn’t an agency. It’s an advantage.

Braymonte partners with founders in tech, finance & healthcare to scale fast with elite marketing, systems, and strategy. This isn’t an agency. It’s an advantage.